EuroKClub

Things Bikers Love (or Hate) => Kit Reviews => Topic started by: raesewell on May 27, 2021, 02:45:59 pm

Title: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: raesewell on May 27, 2021, 02:45:59 pm
Here is an interesting video from Bennetts, a long but worthwhile watch.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x5bMHOS25Mk
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: richtea on May 27, 2021, 03:02:21 pm
Ah, good spot. Another £50 and a bit of testing, and they would have a reasonably good suit. Shame to have spoiled it.
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: sudolea on May 27, 2021, 05:22:51 pm
And this is not even sh.t from Alibaba...   :o
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: Matt on May 27, 2021, 06:55:41 pm
Ah that was interesting! Thanks Rae.

So their needlework seemed OK but they could have dyed with plutonium and they raided a skip for protectors.

And their model had fat wrists.
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: raesewell on May 27, 2021, 07:06:02 pm
I can see you were paying attention Matt  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: richtea on May 27, 2021, 09:08:25 pm
And their model had fat wrists.
Or they didn't take their watch(es) off.

https://bksleather.co.uk/bespoke-service/fit-and-design

- Watches are not normally catered for, as this would mean falsifying one wrist size unsafely. Most motorbikes have a clock for this reason.


Which leads me to ask, now Mr Crowtree (who I loved in a leathery way) has gone to the great Tannery in the Sky, where does one go for bespoke leathers:
- BKS (v v pricey, and playing on their fame)
- Hideout (more sensible pricing)
- RST bespoke
- Dainese bespoke

Any other suggestions?
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: raesewell on May 27, 2021, 09:38:25 pm
https://www.scottleathers.co.uk/
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: richtea on May 27, 2021, 11:34:36 pm
https://www.scottleathers.co.uk/

Thanks Rae.
Barnard Castle. Like it.
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: raesewell on May 28, 2021, 09:20:35 am
I thought that was where Dominic Cummings was heading when he went to test his eyesight  ::)
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: black-k1 on May 28, 2021, 09:25:12 am
I thought that was where Dominic Cummings was heading when he went to test his eyesight  ::)

It was indeed where he went to "test his eyesight", having previously gone into No. 10 and various other meetings after his Mrs had tested positive for COVID.

He really is the epitome of "one rule for them ... "
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: Matt on May 28, 2021, 10:45:19 am
Maybe he was going to the leather place given he seemed to mostly dress as a tramp when he went to number 10, so maybe he thought a leather suit would help!

Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: raesewell on May 28, 2021, 11:27:39 am
OK hands up it was my fault I shouldn't have mentioned DC let's get back on topic.
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: Matt on May 28, 2021, 02:13:49 pm
OK I think possibly the worst thing about that suit was the terrible elbow pucks that didn't match the suit green! Criminal!
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: raesewell on May 28, 2021, 02:16:30 pm
It wouldn't take much effort on the part of the manufacturer to bring this suit up to scratch. A decent lining and a set of protectors.
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: Matt on May 28, 2021, 02:22:29 pm
Ja. Basically they have to beat this:
RST 1 piece, 400 quid (https://www.demon-tweeks.com/uk/rst-2967-r-sport-leather-motorcycle-suit-2009712/). The RST doesn't come with a spine protector but for me at least, I'd rather spec my own. And isn't that around 50 to 100 for a full size one, depending how mad you go?

In any case, if the new kid on the block got to 300 and left out a pocket back protector and put in matching and decent CE level 1 stuff...

RST will probably offer finance! Oh wait they already do.

Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: black-k1 on May 28, 2021, 02:33:41 pm
I'm not sure that I'd put much faith in that RST suit. An A rating means the best bits have manage to survive the 45kmh test. Zones 2 and 3 are less than 45kmh.  I don't know about you but the only time I visit 45kmh (28mph in old money) is twice, once when I pull away and once when I come to a stop.
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: Matt on May 28, 2021, 03:33:52 pm
Ah good point David! Is the no brand working out better on abrasion than that?

Triple A is what we want for my fledgling track day career, but I don't think the no brand will ever be getting there right?
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: Paul R on May 28, 2021, 05:29:07 pm
Hi Rich

I am just in the process of getting a bespoke suit done by DRC in Rotherham - I've only heard of them via  recommendations. https://www.drcleathers.co.uk/

They seem to be very reasonably priced but the racer boys seem to like them so thought I would give them a try. ( Std cow hide but made to measure / spec is £695 )

If you have a couple of months to wait and see ( by the time it's made) I'll gladly put something up on the forum to let you all know what it's like.
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: richtea on May 28, 2021, 05:50:44 pm
Excellent Paul, I'd  really appreciate that.
I'm in no rush, maybe towards the end of the year.

I'm after two-piece, but I guess if they can make a good one-piece, a two-piece isn't a huge step - two zips and an interconnecting 'belt'/thing.

[EDIT: I see they do two-piece: https://www.facebook.com/DRCRaceLeathersUK/photos/a.1260347897730757/1261030107662536]

[EDIT 2: for Matt: https://player.vimeo.com/video/427176264, 3:47 in. With these you wouldn't need those tank grips you put on your last bike!]
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: Matt on May 28, 2021, 06:02:08 pm
Add me to that interested list Paul! If I can stop myself spending even more on having one bike I still mean to get a track disposable one!
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: Paul R on May 29, 2021, 05:39:48 pm
Will do gents.

And Matt, the track day bike is also the way forward......mines a 748 as I'm a glutton for punishment!

If you ever fancy tagging along feel free to drop me a line as I remember quite clearly how disconcerting it can be the first few times.

And BTW, please do not confuse my track enthusiasm for my actual speed. The two are diametrically opposed to each other unfortunately.
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: Paul R on May 12, 2022, 01:32:52 pm
Hi everyone

I know this may be a little late ..............but I did say I would reply...........

Apologies first as the suit did indeed take a while to get sorted by which time I had packed away for the winter months - yes, sorry, that's me.  I've done enough years in the winter to not feel like I have to do it any more for any misguided pleasure.

Anyhoo, so I feel like I can at least comment a little now having worn it for a few months this year, track and road.

The short version is that it is a perfectly comfortable, light suit that feels like it has enough quality in all the right places.  As someone who doesn't know what I am talking about by just looking at it I find it hard to comment whether it would give good/better/best protection should the worst happen.  It feels good and as I think I said before, the racer boys seem happy with them and at least you know you are getting the same as them.

One area where I wonder if it was worth the extra money was the whole idea of having it made to measure.  I'm a fairly regular size and whilst my new suit definitely fits better, it might be difficult to argue that it was worth the extra money - if an off the peg fits you reasonably well.  Although I guess rationality doesn't come into an awful lot of riding bikes in the first place so you can work that one out for yourself.  And if you don't find off the peg fits then it may be a good way forward.

Going back to the service, it was always helpful, courteous and friendly, but I would definitely say that all the stories of it "taking longer than they say" would seem to be justified.  I bumped into someone who had ordered m2m trousers from them and had already been waiting 3 months.

So for me, I would say excellent value for a made to measure suit compared to everywhere else.  Just know what your expectations are
when you order and hopefully it would be as good an experience as I found.

Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: richtea on May 12, 2022, 02:49:42 pm
Thanks for the update Paul. Very useful.

I think all decent bespoke suit makers are busy - that's how they roll, they don't want too much downtime.
You put your name down, and sometime in the next 6 months (if you're lucky) they ring you back.
That's how Crowtree worked.

>  I'm a fairly regular size and whilst my new suit definitely fits better, it might be difficult to argue that it was worth the extra money

A close fit is vital in terms of not having the body armour shift around when you hit something, so I value it. Did they ask you if you're losing weight/putting on weight (in terms of fit)? It's like being at the doctors! The one pair of textiles trousers I chanced to buy went straight back because the knee protectors just swivelled around. Pointless.

Back in the old days, the suits were pretty uncomfy for the first few months whilst the leather eased - especially the elbows for me.
I think the more extensive stretch panels of modern suits probably help dispel most of that now.

Dare I ask the cost, if it's not too rude?
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: Matt on May 12, 2022, 03:07:26 pm
Thanks Paul!

Did you go for the Furygan airbag system too? I had a quick read and other than a frustrating subscription cost it sounded pretty useful (although the Bennetts review I read was circa 2020, so maybe out of date) for a trackday outfit.

Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: Paul R on May 12, 2022, 03:43:05 pm
Happy to answer anything I can.......so for both questions -

Re price, it was as per their std price list - it's £695 for a made to measure, but I opted for the Kangaroo leather for £895.  My last couple of suits were both Kangaroo - as are bits of my gloves - and cos it's thinner it is just that bit lighter and more comfortable. There's also minimal/no breaking in period.  Daft as it may sound, the biggest problem I had was coming up with a design.  I didn't want a replica suit ( I can live without all the advertising ) and didn't want to put something together that after I got it thought "Oh my God, what have I done !!".  But then we all have different tastes !

Their range of off the peg leathers looked very impressive whilst I was there being measured up and may be worth a quick look if you fancied a browse.  And no they didn't ask about inc/dec weight, but they did ask about what specific back/chest protector I had to allow specifically for those.

And re the airbag - I may live to regret it but no, just went without.  In fact there were several add-ons ( like a drinks dispenser in the rear hump ) that I deleted so you do have plenty of choice.  I also didn't do that #NAME thing - I'm quite happy to try and remain anonymous.....

I'm also determined to get out one time when you guys do a group thing so hopefully will come and annoy you at some point shortly  :)
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: Matt on May 12, 2022, 05:00:57 pm
Hm thanks... if it was me and it was just for track days I'd kike "TastyCakes" as the name on the arse. So when people get upset with me they storm over and have to say "oi tastycakes you cut me up on turn 7!" Whilst trying to stay angry :D

I wasn't sure what kangaroos brought to the game. Good to know it's worth it if only for fit!
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: Paul R on May 12, 2022, 05:15:05 pm
Supposedly the roo leather is more abrasion resistant than cow leather. So for the same level of protection it is correspondingly thinner, making it lighter and not requiring as much breaking in.

But then we are told lots of things that aren't always true..........I'm still waiting for a fat man in a red suit to come down a chimney that we don't have one day.......

And I like the tastycakes theory  :D

Maybe you should follow the blackadder option and have 'Captain Darling' on the back.

'Don't you ever do that again.......darling'
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: black-k1 on May 12, 2022, 06:11:43 pm
Roo leather is both more tear resistant and more abrasion resistant than cow leather. It also has thd advantagd that it comes from the bit of the roo (tail I think) that has no pores which makes it much more rain resistant. 

My BKS roo suit has the same protection levels as my old BKS cow leather suit but only weighs about 60% of the old suit.

As someone who has had both, my recommendation would be that if you're paying for a made-to-measure suit then it's worth paying the extra for roo leather.
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: armstrongracer on May 13, 2022, 01:52:51 pm
There is a wee bit more to crash resistance than just static abrasion resistance.  My race suit was RS Taichi, the best I could afford. On track it withstood a very high speed off at Craner Curves with barely a scuff. A few years after I retired from racing I tipped off on an Irish country road at about half the speed of the Craner crash. Suit was fairly badly thrashed. Irish country roads are way rougher than tracks and the tarmac is well worn leaving exposed granite chippings.  This is the problem on roads, chipping are like shark teeth and grab the leather rather than letting it slide. Seams around knee and hip were well stretched, they held up and inferior suits would have opened up like a zipper.  Only place I would trust to do a repair was BKS. Brian actually said that they don't repair other suits but made an exception for mine. He said that when they were developing suits they copied the seam design and stitching from an RS Taichi suit, the best on the market. Essentially construction of the suit is as important as material.
Title: Re: Amazon Leather suit tested
Post by: richtea on May 13, 2022, 02:09:12 pm
Spot on. The type of thread and thread holes per inch are what drives quality construction amongst other things.

It's no good having thread that melts when it gets warm (eeek), or snaps under stress.
Stitch holes too close together and you've weakened the leather. Stitch too far apart and there's not enough holding the seams together.